Best NCAA Tournament Moments from First-Year Players

Though Syracuse fell short against Indiana in the 1987 title game, Derrick Coleman's freshman campaign was nothing short of spectacular. Averaging 10.5 points, 12.2 rebounds, and 2.6 blocks per game, Coleman dominated the paint against future NBA standouts. Had the Orange edged out Bobby Knight’s Hoosiers, Coleman might rank even higher in history.

19. Gene Banks, Duke (1978)

Long before Coach K became synonymous with Duke basketball, Gene Banks took the Blue Devils to the brink of glory. His freshman year was special, averaging 19.2 points and 10.0 rebounds in five tournament contests. Although Kentucky claimed the championship, Banks laid the foundation for Duke’s rise.

18. Gerry McNamara Jr., Syracuse (2003)

Yes, Carmelo Anthony was Syracuse’s marquee name in 2003, but Gerry McNamara was the unsung hero. His sharpshooting—41% from three-point range—and defensive grit (2.5 steals per game) were pivotal. Without McNamara, Syracuse wouldn’t have won their only NCAA crown.

17. Stephon Castle, UConn (2024)

Stephon Castle made his mark with defense, harassing opponents and forcing turnovers during UConn’s second consecutive championship run. Averaging 12.5 points per game, Castle displayed NBA-level composure, especially when he locked down Purdue’s Braden Smith in the title matchup.

16. Patrick Ewing, Georgetown (1982)

Patrick Ewing’s freshman performance in 1982 remains legendary, despite Georgetown’s narrow loss to North Carolina. Scoring 23 points with 11 rebounds and two blocks in the final, Ewing signaled to the basketball world that greatness awaited. Two years later, he delivered a national title.

15. Mike Conley Jr., Ohio State (2007)

Mike Conley's poise and maturity as a freshman point guard were exceptional. Averaging 16 points, 4.8 assists, and 2 steals in the 2007 tournament, he led Ohio State to within striking distance of a championship. His NBA longevity afterward was no surprise.

14. Chris Webber, Michigan (1992)

Chris Webber’s freshman dominance launched the Fab Five phenomenon. Averaging 16.3 points and 9.6 rebounds, he drove Michigan to the title game, only to encounter a historic Duke squad. Webber’s impact, however, remains unforgettable.

13. Jalen Rose, Michigan (1992)

Alongside Webber, Jalen Rose shined brightly throughout the 1992 tournament run. His versatility—17.8 points, 5.6 rebounds, and 5 assists per game—was crucial for Michigan’s success. The Fab Five wouldn’t have been iconic without Rose’s brilliance.

12. Toby Bailey, UCLA (1995)

UCLA owes its 1995 championship to freshman Toby Bailey’s clutch performances. His 26-point, nine-rebound outburst against Arkansas in the title clincher etched his name into Bruins lore, easily earning him all-tournament honors.

11. Jeremy Lamb, UConn (2011)

Kemba Walker got most headlines in 2011, but Jeremy Lamb’s efficiency was equally impressive. Shooting an astonishing 63% from three-point range, Lamb averaged 16.1 points per game. Without his pinpoint accuracy, UConn’s championship run would have stalled.

10. Arnie Ferrin, Utah (1944)

A rare wartime exception allowed freshman Arnie Ferrin to compete—and he made history. Scoring 22 points in the 1944 championship game, Ferrin became the first freshman ever named Most Outstanding Player, forever a cornerstone in Utah’s basketball legacy.

9. Greg Oden, Ohio State (2007)

Playing injured throughout the 2007 tournament, Greg Oden still managed to average 16.1 points and 9.1 rebounds per game. His 25-point performance in the final underscored his toughness, leaving fans forever wondering what might have been had he been fully healthy.

8. Mark Aguirre, DePaul (1979)

Mark Aguirre nearly derailed the iconic Magic vs. Bird matchup in 1979. Averaging 23.4 points on 52% shooting, Aguirre was a freshman phenom who carried DePaul to the brink. His near-miss against Indiana State remains an overlooked gem of NCAA history.

7. Derrick Rose, Memphis (2008)

Derrick Rose’s freshman run with Memphis was electrifying. Averaging 20.8 points and 6 assists, Rose took Memphis to the doorstep of glory. His missed free throw in the final seconds remains haunting, but his remarkable talent was undeniable.

6. Michael Jordan, North Carolina (1982)

Michael Jordan’s game-winning shot against Georgetown in 1982 was the genesis of basketball’s greatest career. Averaging 13.2 points per game in the tournament, Jordan's clutch moment foreshadowed the legendary status to come.

5. Tyus Jones, Duke (2015)

Tyus Jones was the heartbeat of Coach K’s final national title team. His tournament average of 13 points and 4.5 assists, capped by a 23-point championship game masterpiece against Wisconsin, locked his place among Duke’s all-time greats.

4. Mike Bibby, Arizona (1997)

Mike Bibby torched the nets in 1997, averaging 18 points per game and connecting on 49% from deep. His gritty championship-game performance against Kentucky—19 points, nine rebounds—was pivotal in Arizona’s improbable title run.

3. Pervis Ellison, Louisville (1986)

"Never Nervous Pervis" Ellison was a freshman sensation, anchoring Louisville’s 1986 championship. With a 25-point, 11-rebound effort against Duke, he earned Most Outstanding Player honors and solidified his legacy as an all-time freshman great.

2. Anthony Davis, Kentucky (2012)

Anthony Davis’s freshman season was utterly dominant. Averaging 13.6 points, 12.3 rebounds, and nearly 5 blocks per game in the tournament, Davis single-handedly dismantled opponents defensively. His versatility transformed Kentucky into an unstoppable force en route to the 2012 championship.

1. Carmelo Anthony, Syracuse (2003)

Carmelo Anthony’s 2003 run is simply unmatched. Averaging 20.1 points and nearly 10 rebounds per game, he led Syracuse past powerhouse teams like Oklahoma and Texas, before toppling Kansas in the title game. Anthony’s poise, scoring prowess, and leadership made his freshman campaign the finest in NCAA tournament history.

Could Duke’s Cooper Flagg be next to join this elite group? Currently the frontrunner for National Player of the Year and potentially the No. 1 NBA Draft pick this June, all eyes are on Flagg as he attempts to deliver Duke’s sixth national title—and the first under head coach Jon Scheyer.

Basketball fans eager to follow Duke’s run can up the excitement with Bovada Casino. Bovada offers dynamic sports betting opportunities, including NCAA basketball, alongside an array of thrilling casino games powered by Real Time Gaming and Bovada Gaming. New players can take advantage of enticing welcome offers, such as the 125% Bitcoin Welcome Bonus using promo code BTCCW1250. With multiple payment options from Visa to cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Litecoin, Bovada delivers a seamless gaming experience.